Jets roll the dice on undrafted Brady Cook — Could this be “Steal of the year”?

The New York Jets might have skipped selecting a quarterback in the 2025 NFL Draft, but they’re not walking away from the position just yet. In a surprising move, the Jets reportedly signed former Missouri QB Brady Cook as an undrafted free agent. This isn’t just another practice squad addition; it’s a gamble that could either pay off or fade into the background as the Jets continue to juggle their already crowded quarterback room. So, what makes Cook a player worth keeping an eye on and why might his future with the Jets be more intriguing than it seems?



Is Brady Cook just another wild card?





At 6-foot-2 and 214 pounds, Brady Cook certainly has the physical traits that can turn heads. He’s got arm strength, athleticism, and the kind of size that fits the mold of today’s NFL quarterbacks. But here’s the catch, the Jets already have a quarterback room that’s bursting at the seams. Justin Fields and Tyrod Taylor are entrenched in the top two spots, leaving little room for a third QB. Add in Adrian Martinez and Jordan Travis, who are both vying for their place, and it’s clear that Cook faces an uphill battle to even make the roster.


So, why would the Jets take a chance on an undrafted player when they’re already set at the position? Could this move backfire and leave the Jets with a potentially wasted roster spot, or worse, a quarterback who was never meant to be in the NFL? There’s a strong case to be made that this signing could be yet another attempt by the Jets to salvage their quarterback situation, which has been a revolving door of disappointment over the years.


Is Brady Cook the future, or just another miss for the Jets?


Brady Cook may have impressed some scouts with his mobility and arm strength, but NFL experts like Chad Reuter of NFL.com have been careful not to overhype him. He ranks Cook as the No. 3 undrafted free agent QB, acknowledging his raw talent but emphasizing that he needs significant development. Ryan Fowler from The Draft Network also points out Cook’s flaws, including his inconsistency under pressure and inability to make plays downfield with any consistency. So, if Cook struggles to refine his deep ball accuracy and decision-making, is he really worth investing in?


It’s not hard to see why the Jets would take a shot on Cook, but the real question is; Are they setting themselves up for another quarterback disaster? The team’s history of drafting and developing quarterbacks has been nothing short of disastrous, and Cook’s signing may very well be another sign of their inability to secure a reliable starter. While some see potential, others are already predicting this could be just another in a long line of failed Jets quarterback experiments.


Also Read: Shedeur Sanders’ unbelievable NFL Draft slide: Bruce Feldman reveals NFL’s biggest oversight of 2025


At the end of the day, Brady Cook’s future with the Jets will depend on whether he can prove he belongs in the NFL. Going from an undrafted rookie to a reliable quarterback is never easy, and with the Jets' history at the position, the pressure is even higher. If Cook develops the right way, he could carve out a spot; if not, he might simply be another player who didn’t stick around for long.